Justice Vikram Nath and the Stray Dog: A Story of Unexpected Fame

The Indian judiciary is a world of its own, where serious legal battles, complex constitutional matters, and life-changing verdicts are the norm. Yet, sometimes, a seemingly small case can bring about a moment of unexpected humor and global recognition. This is the story of Supreme Court Judge Justice Vikram Nath and the stray dog case that made him known far beyond the hallowed halls of law.

SC judge Justice Vikram Nath says ‘I am thankful to stray dog for making me known’ globally(Supreme Court)

From Legal Luminary to Global Celebrity

For a long time, Justice Nath’s reputation was primarily confined to the legal community. He was a respected judge, known for his diligent work and insightful judgments. But all that changed with one particular case that involved a stray dog. At a recent conference, Justice Nath, with a playful tone, remarked that while he was known for the "little work" he did, he was now thankful to the stray dogs for making him known to the entire civil society, not only in India but the world over. This humorous comment quickly went viral, capturing the hearts of many and highlighting the lighter side of a serious profession.

The turning point was a case that came before a three-judge bench he headed. This bench was tasked with reviewing an earlier, more stringent order from a two-judge bench that had directed municipal authorities to round up stray dogs in Delhi-NCR and not release them from shelters. This earlier decision had sparked widespread anger and protests from animal rights activists and dog lovers, who found the order "too harsh." The case was then shifted to Justice Nath's bench by the Chief Justice of India (CJI) after it was noted that the original order contradicted previous rulings on the matter.

The Verdict That Changed Everything

The verdict delivered by Justice Nath's bench on August 22 was a masterclass in finding a middle ground. His bench modified the earlier order, ruling that stray dogs, after being vaccinated and sterilized, should be released back to the same areas from where they were picked up. The only exceptions were dogs infected with rabies or those exhibiting aggressive behavior. This decision was seen as a victory for animal welfare, striking a balance between public safety and the humane treatment of animals. It was this thoughtful, compassionate, and practical ruling that garnered international attention.

The ripple effect of this case was immediate and far-reaching. Justice Nath shared an anecdote from a recent summit where presidents of lawyers' associations from various countries started asking him questions about the stray dog matter. He expressed how "elated" he felt knowing that people outside India also knew him because of this case. In his own words, he was "thankful to them for giving me this recognition." He even joked that he was receiving messages saying that apart from dog lovers, dogs themselves were giving him blessings and good wishes, adding, "In addition to human blessings and good wishes, I have their good wishes also."

A Broader Look at a Deeper Issue

Beyond the humorous anecdote, the case itself brings to light a significant and often contentious issue in India: the human-wildlife conflict, specifically with stray dogs. While many see stray dogs as a menace, a source of fear and rabies, others advocate for their right to live and be treated humanely. Animal activists argue that the solution is not to simply remove them but to implement effective sterilization and vaccination programs (ABC: Animal Birth Control) to control their population and prevent the spread of diseases. Justice Nath’s ruling aligned with this view, providing a balanced and sustainable solution that respects both human safety and animal welfare.

The case underscored the importance of a nuanced approach to complex societal issues. It showed that legal judgments are not just about applying the letter of the law but also about understanding the spirit of it and its real-world implications. The previous order, which had been widely condemned as cruel and impractical, was a prime example of a solution that failed to consider the broader context and the ethical concerns of a large section of the population. Justice Nath's bench, by contrast, demonstrated a more holistic and compassionate approach.

The Man Behind the Robe

While his recent fame is tied to a lighter matter, Justice Vikram Nath's career has been one of consistent and distinguished service. He was appointed as a judge of the Allahabad High Court and later became the Chief Justice of the Gujarat High Court before being elevated to the Supreme Court. Throughout his career, he has presided over numerous significant cases, and his judgments have been a testament to his legal acumen and commitment to justice. His journey to becoming a Supreme Court judge is a story of hard work, dedication, and a deep understanding of the law.

His humble and lighthearted nature, as seen in his comments on the stray dog case, offers a glimpse into the personality of a man who is not just a judge but also a compassionate human being. It shows that even in the highest echelons of power, there is room for humility and a touch of humor. His ability to connect with the public on such a relatable issue has not only boosted his personal fame but has also, in a way, humanized the judiciary, making it seem less distant and more approachable.

The Unforgettable Legacy of a Stray Dog

In a world filled with conflict and division, the story of Justice Vikram Nath and the stray dog is a refreshing reminder of our shared humanity and our capacity for kindness. The case, which was about finding a solution for a public issue, became a vehicle for a heartwarming anecdote that resonated with people globally. It’s a testament to the fact that sometimes, the most memorable stories are not the ones about grand achievements, but the ones that touch upon our most basic emotions: empathy, compassion, and a good-natured laugh.

Justice Nath’s remarks were not just a funny quip; they were a profound statement about how a single act of kindness or a single wise decision can have an impact far beyond its initial scope. He has now become an emblem of compassion and a testament to the power of a single, well-thought-out legal judgment. He is not just Justice Vikram Nath, the esteemed judge; he is now Justice Vikram Nath, the man who was made famous by a stray dog.